Well, it’s that time of year again, 40 runners, 4 and a half miles, it must be the Grand National!
Trying to weigh up the chances of each horse in such a large field is a daunting task so I am going to take a few short cuts.
Traditionally weight has proved to be a crucial factor in the Aintree puzzle. Since 1983 only one horse has carried more than 11 stone to victory, and that was Hedgehunter who won with 11 stone 1 on his back. For starters then I am going to take out the top 7 in the weights; all those carrying 11 stone 6 or more. That includes Hegehunter himself, probably the best jumper in the field and the Becher Chase winner, Mr Pointment. They simply have too much weight.
So far so good – we only have 33 runners to worry about. Next to go are all the runners aged 6 and 7 as no horse in that age band has won since Pontious was a pilot. Out go Opera Mundi, Iron Man, No Full, Bob Hall, Milan Deux Mille and Nadover. Right, now we only have 27.
The National is over 4.5 miles so stamina is an important attribute for any potential winner. I am going to remove next all those horses that have not won a race over at least 3 miles. This gets rid of Fundamentalist, King John’s Castle, Contraband and Tumbling Dice. Now we have 23
I want to remove 3 more now. Idle Talk has unseated his rider 5 times in his last 10 runs and in a race where jumping is so important he has to go. Martin Pipe saddles 3 horses in the race. Timmy Murphy had the choice of which one to ride and he chose Comply or Die so I am putting a line through the other two, Vodka Bleu and Joacci. Now we have cut the field on half and have 20 possibles. It is time to examine them one by one.
Butler’s Cabin has two very good bits of form. Last season he won both the Irish National and a 4 miler at the Cheltenham Festival. He is ridden by Tony McCoy which has to be another plus. On the negative side he has done nothing this season and his stable have been in and out of form. He has to be considered on the strength of those two wins last season but he is not going on my short list.
Slim Pickings ran a great race in 3rd last season. He has been campaigned this time round with the National in mind. He is higher in the weights this time and although I wouldn’t be surprised to see him in the first 6 I don’t think he will win.
Chelsea Harbour won over 3.5 miles at Punchestown in February in desperate ground carrying 11 stone 10. He clearly has plenty of stamina and a good attitude. He has had 9 runs this season though so quite a hard campaign, his jumping can let him down and he might be best on soft ground so I am going to pass him over.
L’Ami is a horse I have always liked. He once came 4th in a Gold Cup and ran a good race in 3rd at the Cheltenham Festival this season. He does not win very often though and he could only finish 10th last year so I don’t see what grounds there are for tipping him this time.
Snowy Morning was 2nd to Denman at Cheltenham last season and many people have latched on to that performance when rating this horse’s chances. Ruby Walsh has chosen not to ride him, opting for Hedgehunter instead and that, combined with the fact that the horse is best on soft ground puts me off him.
Bewley’s Berry is interesting. He was going well in the race last season when falling (he actually crumpled on landing) and he has twice finished runner up in the Becher Chase over the National fences. One for the shortlist.
McKelvey was 2nd last year and possibly unlucky not to win. He suffered an injury in the latter stages of the race but has come back to run twice over hurdles since the turn of the year. He was 6th in the Becher Chase of 2006 over the National fences and showed he handles a firm surface when winning the Summer National at Uttoxeter over an extended 4 miles on good to firm. As long as he has got over that injury he must go on the short list.
Point Barrow was my tip last year and he fell at the first! He is a former winner of the Irish National but has worn blinkers in his last 3 races and blinkered runners have a terrible record in the Grand National.
D’Argent has a good record at left handed tracks, won at Warwick in January over 3 miles 5 and comes from the in form Alan King stable. He stays well as he was 2nd in last year’s Midlands National over 4 miles 1.5 furlongs and he comes to Aintree on the back of a decent effort in the Red Square Vodka Gold Cup at Haydock where he was 4th in what is often a good Grand National trial. He goes on the short list.
Baily Breeze hasn’t won over 3 miles since winning at Thurles over 3 years ago and that was in a slow run race. I can’t have him.
Cloudy Lane is very well handicapped as he has won twice since the weights were announced. He is trained by the McCain family of Red Rum fame, and he has won his last 3 races all at Grade 1 tracks. He jumps well and the ground will suit him. He has won over 3.25 miles but here remains a slight doubt in my mind that he will quite get the 4.5. He has to go on the short list though.
Mon Mome is a consistent individual. If you look at his wins it doesn’t look all that impressive but he has run some fine races in defeat. He was runner up in the Kim Muir at the Festival in ’06, 2nd in the Welsh National in ’06, 2nd in the Warwick Classic in ’07, 3rd in the Red Square Vodka in ’07 and 4th in the William Hill Trophy at last year’s festival. One for the short list.
Cornish Sett was 2nd at Cheltenham in November over 3.5 miles, will like the ground and has a touch of class. He looks like the 3rd string from his stable though if we go by jockey bookings.
Naunton Brook stays well as evidenced by his win over 4 miles at Hexham and he was 4th in this year’s Welsh National. He is a bold jumper and may well be up with the leaders for some of the way. He didn’t get round last season though and I don’t think he is quite good enough.
Backbeat has had injury problems but won over 3 miles at Sandown earlier in the season. I think there are more obvious candidates.
Comply or Die is interesting as he has a touch of class and won the Eider Chase at Newcastle this year over 4 miles 1 furlong so clearly stays. He wears blinkers though and runners with headgear have an abysmal record in the National. This might be something to do with not being able to see what is happening around them in a 40 runner packed field.
Kelami is L’Ami’s brother. He won the William Hill Trophy in 2005 and was a good second at Kempton on his latest start. He was pulled up in the National last year though.
Black Apalachi has been running well in good handicaps in Ireland without actually winning. There are worse outsiders.
Philson Run is a dour stayer and was 4th last year. He has stamina in abundance and good form over marathon trips.
Dun Doire has been aimed at this race by his very canny trainer. A former winner of the William Hill Trophy he was pulled up last season and is best on soft ground.
Ardaghey has come in as a reserve to replace Opera Mundi. He has won 3 times over 3 miles.
Summary
There is no doubt that Cloudy Lane is very well handicapped. If he gets the trip and doesn’t encounter any traffic problems he looks the most likely winner. His price is short though. If you want to back him I would suggest a win only bet as if he doesn’t get the trip he is unlikely to figure in the finish.
I like horses with proven ability over the fences. Hedgehunter is a wonderful horse but just has too much weight, as does Becher Chase winner Mr Pointment, although both may well get round. Last season’s 2nd, 3rd and 4th all reappear. Philson’s Run really needs a slog in the mud and while I can see Slim Pickings being in the first 6 I don’t think he will win. McKlevey on the other hand likes Aintree and if he has shrugged off his injury must go close.
The French brothers L’Ami and Kelami may have had their chance although either could be in the first 10.
Both Simon and Bewley’s Berry were going well when coming down last season. Simon has the best chance of those at the top of the weights but I just feel that the weight will tell. Bewleys Berry has twice finished 2nd in the Becher Chase. I have a slight doubt about his stamina but if he lasts home I would fancy him.
Mon Mome is a consistent sort and I can see him creeping into 4th place.
The Alan King stable are in red hot form and I have to include his runner D’Argent. He stays longer than the mother in law and is he takes to the fences he could be there or thereabouts.
Final answer? I like Bewley’s Berry, I can see last season’s placed horses McKelvey and Slim Pickings being in the first 4 again, Mon Mome is consistent and could get a place while Black Apalachi and D’Argent are my suggested outsiders. Whatever else you back a saver of Cloudy Lane would probably make sense.
Good luck!