Review of the flat 2009 – Part 1

 

Just as Charles Dickens used to serialize his novels I am going to offer you my review of the flat in bite sized chunks. I have chosen 75 horses that for one reason or another caught my attention last season and they will appear on this small but perfectly formed web site in the time honoured “reverse order.” What larks as Joe Gargery used to say to Pip in Great Expectations!

Numbers 71 to 75

OK, what has crept into the end of this elite list? When compiling my list or horses to follow for the 2009 flat season I added a 7 year old called Woodsley House on the strength of a hat trick of wins in 2008. I looked up his trainer in my “Horses in training” book and found that AG Foster had about 20 in his string and operated at Cousland, Midlothian and one of my well informed friends told me that this was a stable to “look out for.” After his first 3 runs in which he did not figure prominently he lined up in a 7 furlong handicap at Musselburgh. On my web site preview I wisely commented that he had returned to his last winning mark but would appreciate some cut in the ground. Under what the racing pundits described as “an enterprising ride” by Neil Brown Woodsley House duly won at 20/1 on good to firm (how much do I know anyway!)

The assessor put Woodsley House up 3 lbs to a mark of 71 as a result of his win and I decided to keep a watching brief for a while. In the event he ran another 11 times without troubling the judge again and as during that losing sequence he came down to a mark of 63 I periodically became quite enthusiastic about his chances but sadly that success up in Scotland was not to be repeated.

The number 74 spot goes to a horse that, at the time of penning these notes, had run 125 times, and won 16 of them. There are not many 12 year olds still campaigning on the flat but evergreen sprinter The Tatling (pictured below) is still going strong. He used to contest group races at the top tracks and in October 2005 contested the Group 1 Prix De L’Abbaye at Longchamp with his career best win coming in the King’s Stand at Ascot in 2004. . Those heady days involving visits to Paris have gone and he often runs on the all weather now but he ran consistently in 2009 winning on turf at Bath and Newbury, not bad for a 12 year old.

the tatling

I am reliably informed that only 15% of racehorses win a race during their careers. Such is the handicapping system that winning multiple races in a season is no mean achievement. A horse called Trip The Light (by Fantastic Light pictured below) managed to win 3 times in 2008 going from a rating of 46 to 71 in the process. Now you would think that such a horse would be difficult to place the following season but Trip The Light surpassed his efforts in 2008 by winning 4 handicaps during 2009, an achieve worthy of position number 73 in my list. For those interested in such things the horse has never won a race where there was an “s” in the official going description.

fantastic light

For number 72 I have chosen Mooakada, a 3 year old trained by John Gosden. This is the only horse in my “75” that never actually won a race during the season. As a horse to follow though he came very close to being more profitable that any of the others on the list. He twice finished runner up at odds of 20/1, in listed races at Yarmouth and Doncaster.

If following Mooakada would not have made you rich the horse in the number 71 spot fared hardly any better from a profit point of view as his only win came at odds of 1/5. Given that the race took place at Wolverhampton and was worth £2,590.40 to the winner it would be fair to question to ask how La De Two has found his way onto the “75.” In reality he went into many a notebook as a juvenile as on his only start he finished second at Doncaster splitting Kite Wood and Monitor Closely who went on to finish 2nd and 3rd in the St Leger. La De Two didn’t appear in 2009 until his Wolverhampton race the day after Firework Night by which time he had gone from his original trainer Barry Hills to Godolphin. Presumably his late arrival on the scene in 2009 was the result of a problem of some sort but although he didn’t beat much at Wolverhampton he at least showed his well being and may yet be able to fulfil his potential.

The next instalment featuring numbers 61 to 70 will appear shortly. I bet you can hardly contain your excitement! My thanks to the artist Lisa Miller for use of the pictures of The Tatling and Fantastic Light.

Diary: November 23 2009

The best meeting tomorrow is at Kempton with supporting cards at Ffos Las and Ludlow.

Nicky Henderson introduces an interesting “new signing” in the novice hurdle at Kempton at 12.20 in the shape of the five year old Candy Creek. This mare won twice in 3 starts in bumpers last season with the latest success coming at Aintree in a very competitive contest. The only defeat was when 4th to the Cheltenham festival winner Dunguib at Navan. Tony McCoy rides Candy Creek and the same trainer/jockey combination has a good chance in the 12.50 with the recent Ascot winner You’re the Top who is on a 4 timer.

McCoy and Henderson team up again in the 1.25 where they have another live chance with My Petra although here they face stiff opposition from the Donald McCain runner Whiteoak. Another that could run well in this is Dansimar. Whiteoak would be my selection.

Kauto Star tracks Imperial Commander on his way to victory

Charlie Mann saddles Cast Cada in the 2.00 which is a beginner’s Chase. A former point to point winner Cast Cada won twice over hurdles last season and made a pleasing start to his career over fences when 2nd at Uttoxeter recently.

At Ludlow the 12.30 features some promising horses. Abbevilian had some decent bumper form before finishing 4th to Dave’s Dream on his hurdles debut last Christmas. He should be capable of winning races on that evidence. Royal Collonges is another to look out for. He is a half brother to the high class chaser Neptune Collonges.

Today’s picture, of Kauto Star and Imperial Commander, is by courtesy of Kate Tann.

Diary: November 22 2009

 

I am a bit short of time tonight so I have tried to pick out a few runner of interest from each of the  meetings tomorrow.

At Aintree the consistent Wendel likes plenty of give in the ground and should have conditions to suit him in the 1.10. 

Aintree 09_Foxhunters Chase, Canal Turn - Twilight Trix, Ballybough Jack, Theatre Knight, Christy Beamish

Border Tale is on a mark he should be competitive from.  He runs in the handicap hurdle at 12.50 up at Musselburgh but in his case the rain needs to stay away.  Classy hurdler Tazbar makes his chase debut in the 1.25.  He should win this on his way to bigger and better things over fences.

At Towcester my best bet is Lady Carolina a winning pointer who showed promise over hurdles when second at Southwell in February.

At Navan Good Fella could run well at a big price in the 2.35 while my two against the field in the 3.05 are Sports Line and Solstice Knight.

My thanks to Sarah Clegg for the photo of horses jumping the Canal Turn at Aintree.

Diary: November 21 2009

There is top class racing tomorrow at both Ascot and Haydock. Starting at Ascot the mare’s handicap hurdle at 1.30 is being run for the first time so we have no stats to guide us from past seasons. The two that head the weights, Easter Legend and Ravello Bay, are my fancies. The latter had a consistent campaign last season with form figures that read 2132. Only beaten a short head by Argento Luna at Newbury on his last start he could still be well treated. Easter Legend has shown a tenacious attitude in her races and finished last season with a battling second to a Paul Nicholls runner in a competitive handicap at Cheltenham in April. Ravello Bay looks the most likely winner with Easter Legend in with an each way shout.

In the 2.05 I think the winner will come from either Cornas or Master Medic.

The Ascot Hurdle at 2.35 is a particularly intriguing contest and a case could be made for all 8 runners. The presence of front runner Lough Derg should make it a true test so the winner will need to get the trip. Straw Bear has not enjoyed himself over fences and reverts to the smaller obstacles here. He does of course have top class from over timber having won the Christmas Hurdle at Kempton back in 2007. Red Moloney was a smart horse on the flat and won 3 times over hurdles last season. He likes a flat track but his recent defeat at the hands of Katies Tutor leads me to think that there are others in the field tomorrow with a better chance. The admirable Katchit (pictued below) has a Champion Hurdle on his CV but failed to win a race last season and although he might make the frame I can’t see him winning somehow.

Katchit

Elusive Dream injured himself at Ascot last Christmas and didn’t make much impression on his recent comeback run. He is a horse that likes decent ground. Triumph Hurdle winner Zaynar gives the impression that he will stay this longer trip. Time For Rupert is a likable sort who ended last season by winning a valuable handicap hurdle at Aintree over an extended 3 miles. Finally, Karabak who was runner up in the Ballymore Novices Hurdle and is a course and distance winner is another to consider seriously. Time For Rupert could go well at a decent price but Zaynar and Karabak may well fight out the finish.

The Grade 2 chase at 3.10 features a couple of real old favourites in Monet’s Garden and Voy Por Ustedes as well as promising newcomer Planet of Sound. Monet’s Garden has only run at Ascot twice, winning one and finishing runner up to Kauto Star. He also has the benefit of a recent run, and that a winning one. Voy Por has not won first time out in any of the last 3 seasons but there may have been excuses each time. I will give Alan King’s horse my selection.

At Haydock the consistent SA Suffitt carries top weight in the 12.45 although talented conditional Harry Haynes is excellent value for his 5 lbs claim. Two miles might be a bit short for SA Suffitt but in testing conditions that might not matter so much. He is consistent and should go well having won on soft ground before.

I liked the way that Mr Thriller won at Chepstow last month and I will take him to follow up in the 1.15. Peddler’s Cross won his only Irish point to point and is well regarded by connections. He should go well in the 1.45.

The 2.20 over the fixed brush hurdles at Haydock is a competitive looking affair. Diamond Harry may well start favourite on the back of a successful hurdles campaign last season where his only defeat came when far from disgraced in the Ballymore Hurdle. He gets on well with jockey Timmy Murphy and the stable are in good form. Pause and Clause was 3rd in the Coral Cup last season and should be suited by these obstacles as he has already been schooled over fences. The soft ground may be against him tomorrow however. Wendel will not mind the ground as he won on heavy at Ascot last season. He jumps well and travels in his races and at around 14/1 there are worse outsiders. Recent Kelso winner McMurrough is another to consider although soft ground would probably not be in his favour. The consistent Pennek stays well and like most of these will be going novice chasing in due course. He won on the soft in France so the ground should be OK. Ring the Boss is another for the short list although the stable form could give cause for concern. I have followed Diamond Harry from the start of his career and I would like to see him win here – he may well do so but he does have his quirks. Wendel the mudlark has each way claims as does the honest Pennek.

In the Betfair Chase it would seem to be between the first 5 in the betting. The testing ground will suit Halcon Generlardais but he has always looked just short of the very top class and unless this turned into a real mudbath I don’t think he will have the necessary gears. Imperial Commander seems to struggle over this trip and is passed over for that reason. Madison Du Berlais is useful on his day and as long as all 8 runners stand their ground he looks the each way bet in the race. Notre Pere will love the ground but comes into the race after a fall at Down Royal. He has a stone to find with Kauto Star but he stays well and is likely to try and run the finish out of his distinguished rival. Kauto Star (pictured below) has an impressive strike rate and has won this twice in the past. He can put in the odd substandard run but he is entitled to be ranked with the all time greats and should prevail.

kauto star

In the 3.25 The Vicar can give Henrietta Knight a win. A course winner on heavy ground when accounting for subsequent winner SA Suffit last season he ticks the right boxes.

At Huntingdon I like High Jack and War Footing in the 1.35. On the basis that the rgound may not be soft enough for War Footing I will narrowly prefer High Jack. In the 2.45 Borora may find the trip on the sharp side and the two I prefer are Bob Bob Bobbin, a very good second at Aintree recently and the evergreen Mister McGoldrick from the in form stable of Sue Smith. The latter has a very capable conditional jockey reducing his weight and gets the nod.

There is an inspection planned at Gowran Park in the morning. If racing goes ahead my selection is Taking Stock in the 1.40.

Today’s pictures are courtesy of the artist Lisa Miller.

Diary: November 20 2009

There is a lot of satisfaction to be derived from tipping a horse that actually wins, so imagine my jubilation when 3 of the blighters that I tipped last night managed to get their heads in front. Fair enough the odds were skinny (and in one case positively suffering from malnutrition!). Still a winner is a winner and if you got on early you could have had 6/4 about Sereth.

The well fancied Paul Nicholls runner Vico was beaten today (although I wouldn’t write him off just yet) and Nicholls has another likely favourite in the Ascot 12.55 tomorrow in Red Harbour. He has the course form having won twice in bumpers at the Berkshire track last season but he was a little disappointing on his hurdles debut at Exeter where he could only finish 3rd. It is possible that the heavy ground that day counted against him and although rain is forecast for Ascot tomorrow that track rarely gets too soft these days. Emma Lavelle saddles another fancied runner in this with Prior’s Glen who ran well in a couple of decent bumpers last season. The winners of both those races have since been beaten when reappearing over obstacles which perhaps tempers the enthusiasm a tad. Red Harbour may well win but his price will be short, artificially so perhaps and I will take a chance on Prior’s Glen as the value.

3339024781_dcc08eda00

Nicky Henderson saw a couple of his novice chasers win today and saddles another promising recruit tomorrow in Zemsky who runs in the 1.30. A winner over hurdles at Plumpton and Perth last season he also has a couple of Irish point to point successes on his CV which is encouraging for a would be steeplechaser.

Alan King’s horses have tended to need their initial run of the season but one that managed to win impressively first time out was Manyriverstocross at Chepstow. He looks to follow up in the Ascot 2.05. Chepstow form does not always translate to other tracks but this horse was useful on the flat and has strong claims. The highly rated bumper winner Vino Griego is likely to be his main danger but Manyriverstocross is the selection.

Aconitum and Tara Taylor I the two I like in the 3.35 at Exeter. The latter has the assistance of AP McCoy which is no bad thing and both ground and trip should suit. Tara Taylor is the selection.

Bumper winner Wymott was second on his hurdles debut and should go well in the 12.15 at Kelso. The extra distance shouldn’t trouble him and he is my idea of the winner.

Little Josh fell on his last outing but based on previous hurdles and chase form he looks the one to be on in the 1.50.

Finally, Garleton was entered in the Northumberland National the other day when the Hexham meeting was washed out.  He runs in the Kelso 3.00 tomorrow and the stable clearly have confidence in his stamina.  He comes into the race in good form and Sue Smith had a winner this week with Nirvana Swing.  Garleton looks the one they have to beat in this.

Today’s picture is by courtesy of Emily Russell.

Diary; November 19 2009

 

Nirvana Swing gained a well deserved win at Market Rasen this afternoon. He is a typical big staying chaser from Sue Smith’s yard and was well ridden by his conditional jockey. Ballybriggan was second in his race and should be up to winning a race or two and with the only Irish selection coming in, albeit at cramped odds it wasn’t such a bad day.

Starting with the meeting at Hereford tomorrow Ballingaddy looks an interesting runner in the 3.20. He won a point to point at Athenry in April 2008 before joining Alan King. His best effort under rules was a 4th at Doncaster in January. Off a mark of 95 and with Charlie Huxley taking 3 lbs off he looks value at around 10/1.

Sereth won 5 times on the flat in Germany including couple of listed races. His best effort in the UK was when 3rd behind Darley Sun in the Cesarewich. If he takes to hurdling then his class on the flat will make him difficult to beat in the 12.40 at Huntingdon tomorrow.

2008_0210RacesFeb_0097

There is a very hot novice chase at 2.10. Micheal Flips, Dave’s Dream and Numide are all exciting prospects having shown a decent level of form over hurdles. Dave’s Dream has always looked a chaser in the making and with AP McCoy in the saddle I will burden him with my selection.

Vico won both his point to points in the west country and is rated a top prospect at the Paul Nicholls stable. He makes his hurdling debut in the 1.00 at Wincanton tomorrow.

Carole’s Legacy has decent form both in bumpers and over hurdles and should make a winning debut over fences in the 2.00.

My thanks to Ruth S Harris for her photo of Hereford racecourse.

Diary: November 18 2009

Garleton won at Hexham on his seasonal reappearance and returns to that track tomorrow for the Northumberland National over 4 miles at 2.20. He won twice over fences last season and has had a wind operation since. He jumps well in the main but his better form has been on good ground and there may be a question mark over his ability to handle testing conditions over such a marathon trip. I will stick with him although the ground is a concern.

Bakkybriggan won a bumper last season at Wetherby when he was trained by Victor Dartnall. He has changed stables since and John Quinn runs him at Market Rasen in the novice hurdle at 12.40. He looked to have plenty of potential when winning his bumper.

Nirvana Swing has finished runner up on his last two starts and deserves to get his head in front. He runs in the 2.10.

Market Rasen Racecourse.

Picaroon won at Market Rasen last Boxing Day but disappointed when he next visited the Lincolnshire track in the summer. His last run when 5th to Harry Tricker at Sandown was not a bad effort and he is worth considering in the 2.40. In the same race Friendly King, a winner at Fakenham last season, does not look on a bad mark. This is a tricky race with the likely favourite River Logic from a stable bang in form. I am going to take a chance with the outsider Friendly King.

At Clonmel Fionnegas comes into the 12.35 with a 100% record. He looks a progressive sort and is difficult to oppose.

My thanks to David Hebb for use of his photo of “the betting jungle” at Market Rasen.

Diary: November 17 2009

 

Last night’s preview yielded a couple of odds on winners and a 10/1 second so not too bad.

The meeting at Folkestone tomorrow looks quite interesting and there are a couple of horses that I have been waiting for in the 1.10. Rigadin de Beauchene is a half brother to a Welsh National winner and will probably need further than this trip in time. He showed enough in his couple of runs in bumpers to suggest there is more to come and he is one to keep an eye on. For this race though I prefer Aegean Dawn, another well related individual who impressed many good judges when winning a bumper at Kempton in February.

I also considered Vodka Brook (1.40) and Nikos Extra (2.40) although neither would want the ground too testing.

Diary: November 16 2009

 

There are jumps meetings at Leicester, Plumpton and Cork tomorrow. At Leicester I will put up Devon Native as a “sporting” bet. A winner at Southwell in the summer a recent run at Uttoxeter should put her spot.

There are a couple of interesting runners in the Plumpton 1.50. Coin of the Realm won on the flat at Epsom in the summer. On his previous efforts over hurdles he has raced a little too keenly but if he settles he should go close. The Betchworth Kid makes his hurdles debut. Rated over 100 on the flat he was 3rd in the Goodwood Cup this year and if he can jump he will be a very useful recruit to the winter game.

hurdlers_race_plumpton

In the 2.20 Bensalem makes his eagerly awaited chase bow for trainer Alan King. His only defeat over hurdles last season came at the hands of Diamond Harry in a Grade 2 and he looks just the sort to make a chaser. Den of Iniquity is another runner to look out for in this race. He has always appealed as a chaser in the making.

Luska Lad was 3rd in a hot race at Down Royal the other week. He looks to have an easier task in the 1.30 at Cork tomorrow and is the selection.

Today’s picture is courtesy of Katy Sodeau.